by Nancy Armitage

Sadly, I never found a “Thanksgiving Menu” of the Huntington Family. I know that the Huntingtons often had Thanksgiving Dinner at Archer & Helen Huntington house at his mansion in Pelham Bay NY. Both Arabella Huntington’s & her son, Archer Thanksgiving dinner menu would have leaned towards Southern cuisine: like Roasted Turkey & Cornbread Stuffing or Oyster dressing, Giblet Gravy,& Sweet Potato Pie, etc.
I did find some invoices (November & December) & recipes they could have been used for the Huntington Thanksgiving & Christmas festivities. In the 1880’s-1890’s, the Collis & Arabella Huntington’s most-likely spent Thanksgiving at Throgg’s Neck “Huntington’s Homestead” estate (by the seaside) or at their New York Mansion at No. 2 57th St. NYC. But, there were times that Archer & his 1st wife, Helen Huntington, hosted the Huntington Family Thanksgiving Dinner.

In the 1890’s, when Archer Huntington (Arabella Huntington’s son) was married to his 1st wife, Helen Gates Huntington, they hosted Thanksgiving Dinner [Huntington Woods now – Pelham Bay]. In 1922 &1923, The H. E. Huntingtons – “Arabella & Edwards” (HEH) were at the San Marino Ranch in Southern California. In 1924,1925 and 1926, widower Henry E. Huntington spent Thanksgiving at the San Marino Ranch in Southern California.

In America, many Thanksgiving dinners are served in the afternoon or early evening, its such a large meal. Often, the guests have a light lunch or no lunch, because of the big feast ahead. So the hostess is smart to put out some yummy nibbles for hungry guests, maybe toasted almonds or mixed nuts or Chex mix with nuts.

Appetizers & Nibbles on Thanksgiving Day:
Passed appetizers on silver trays, (doily-lined) & a Thanksgiving paper cocktail napkin.
Classic Deviled Eggs with paprika and minced peppercorns on top (on a oval 12-section egg plate). Southern Style Deviled Eggs could be the use of Dijon French mustard with mayonnaise, or dill pickle relish; maybe Mrs. Huntington spooned a little caviar on top.
Mrs. Huntington’s Roquefort Puffs (simple recipe: mixture of mayo, parmesan cheese, minced onion, crumbled Roquefort cheese, mix and spread this mixture on bread rounds (1 1/2″) use cookie cutter. Using butter knife or baby spoon spread the cheese mixture top of the bread. Place cheese rounds on cookie sheet. Bake on cookie sheet for 425 for 15 mins. until golden brown. Serve on a doily-lined silver tray.
Southern Sausage Balls with a toothpick
Bowl of whole nuts with nutcracker like walnuts, pecans, almonds, & pistachios
Southern Fried Okra with spicy Mayonnaise Sauce or French Aioli
Toasted or sautéed Slivered Almonds with (salt and butter) in a bowl
Southern Hush Puppies (fried Sausage, onion, cornmeal, & cheese & Herb ball with Cajun seasoning)

In the 1880’s & 1890’s, in the Gilded Age, they had 8-16 multi-course dinners. Each course paired with white & red wines &French champagne & California champagne. Especially on large & festive occasions like banquets & holidays like Thanksgiving, Christmas, & New Years. Elegant meals especially at New York’s Delmonico’s restaurant or private clubs or fancy hotels, this menu could have been served.

A typical Thanksgiving Dinner during the Gilded Age would have started with
Blue Point Oysters on the Half Shell or Oyster Soup or Light Consommé or Bouillon, Fish course: Whitebait or Red Snapper. Main Course: Roasted Turkey with Giblet Gravy, Oyster Dressing or Corn Bread & Sausage Dressing, Mashed Potatoes, Sweet Potato & Marshmallow Casserole, Virginia Ham with Glaze, Cranberry Relish with Mandarin Oranges and Pecans, Game Course like Duck a la Orange, Quail, Pheasant or Chicken, French Petit Pois or French Green Beans with Toasted Slivered Almonds, Squash, Cheese Course with Grapes & Fruits, Waldorf Salad,
Desserts like Royal Diplomate Pudding, Sweet Potato Pie, Apple Pie, Mincemeat Pie, Pumpkin Pie, Pecan Pie served with Vanilla Bean Ice Cream, Petit Pecan Tarts, Chocolate BonBon (French truffles), Fancy Cakes, & Coffee, Autumnal Nuts, & Candies.

Southern Huntington Thanksgiving Dinner Menu:
Compiled from Huntington menus & invoices & other seasonal dinners:
Huntington “Champagne Punch” & Roquefort Puffs (served to guests from a silver platter), maybe serviced in the Large Library before walking into the formal Dining-Room
Raw Shucked Oysters on the Half Shell to start with Mignonette Sauce or Baked Oyster New Orleans style with Hollandaise sauce
Soup: Oyster Soup, or New Orleans Gumbo
Appetizers: Canapes Lorenzo (Spicy Crab Canape), Victorian Cheese Sticks with Cayenne Pepper
Relish dish: Queen Olives, Black California Olives, Toasted Almonds, & Celery Sticks
Fish Course: Crab Cake Balls or Crab Puffs
Entrée Course: Roasted Turkey (San Marino Ranch) with Giblet Gravy served with French Champagne Moet & Chandon Champagne
Southern Oyster Herb Stuffing with sausage, onions & celery, with savory herbs & oysters (maybe bacon & scallions)
or Southern Cornbread & Savory Sausage stuffing with onions & celery with cornbread made with buttermilk, sage, thyme & to moisten chicken stock, & milk
Sweet Potato Casserole with brown sugar or Marshmallows & chopped Pecans on top
Southern Gourmet Green Bean Casserole: with sautéed onions, garlic & mushrooms in butter & heavy cream with green beans. Place in casserole top with mozzarella cheese & top with crispy French fried onions /or Cream of Mushroom Soup & Green Beans or San Marino Steamed French Green Beans with Toasted slivered Almonds &/or Crispy Bacon & Sautéed Onions
Garlic Mashed Potatoes or “Mashies” (Mashed Potato Casserole with garlic, cream cheese, sour cream & topped with bread crumbs & parmesan cheese & baby chives and bake)
Creamed Spinach with onions & garlic, heavy cream & cream cheese topped with Parmesan cheese or
Southern Collard Greens or Southern Sautéed Mustard Greens with scallions, oil, & red chili flakes or cayenne
Best Corn Casserole with creamed corn & corn muffin mix, eggs, milk, & heavy cream, paprika & chives [Mrs. Pickett’s Corn Pudding – Civil War recipe – Mr. Huntington had a copy of her recipe in his San Marino Ranch desk- in his small office]
Creamy Macaroni & Cheese (add Lobster)
Cranberry Sauce or “Cranberry Relish” (Howies Ranch Market, San Gabriel CA) -cooked and cooled cranberries minced with mandarin orange, walnuts, ginger & apples)
Homemade Southern Buttermilk Biscuits or Parkerhouse Rolls served with sweet honey butter
Salad: San Marino Tomato Aspic with Baby Shrimp
Desserts: American Pumpkin Pie, Southern Sweet Potato Pie, Apple pie, & petit Mincemeat tarts
Southern Pecan pie, or Petit Pecan Tassies (Petit pecan tartlette)
After-dinner Liqueurs: Crème de Menthe & Soda Water/Ginger Ale (great digestive) and a Thanksgiving walk

Thanksgiving Cranberry Relish recipe
Any portions works. This is so delicious & refreshing relish; make the day before Thanksgiving to let the flavors mingle.
grated apple (Granny Smith)
grated fresh Cranberries or blend in ninja blender (cooked so they are not so bitter)
orange zest & juice to moisten
pecans or walnuts, minced
mandarin oranges, chopped
fresh ginger, grated
Place in blender and blend until chopped. In a crystal bowl, mix all together & refrigerate overnight.

Huntington Thanksgiving Tea Party (Belle’s No. 2 Mansion, NYC) or “At-Home” tea gathering were held at the Huntington Mansion on Tuesdays at No. 2. Information from a Mr. H. E. Huntington’s gourmet food market below. Between November & early December (1919), there were a lot of tea goodies ordered for the H. E. Huntington household at No. 2 NYC. The Huntington Invoice is below from Park & Tilford Gourmet Market, NYC.

Thanksgiving Teaparty Menu:
Huntington Tea Blend (India & Ceylon mix = Orange Pekoe ) or Pkg. of 5 o’clock tea blend (1900’s)
Mrs. Huntington Thanksgiving Champagne Punch with Apple Cider & Welch’s Grape drink with Champagne with cinnamon sticks & sweet spices (Adults)
Children’s Sparkling Martinelli’s Apple Cider (with sliced oranges & lemons & floating on top in a large punch bowl)
Nut Bowl: Virginia Peanuts, Walnuts, & Pecans in bowls with nut crackers
Jordan’s Almonds in a footed silver bowls (a favorite of Mrs. Huntington)
Tea Sandwiches: Deviled Egg Salad Sandwiches, Chicken Salad Sandwiches, Cranberry & Turkey Sandwiches, Salmon Pate, Pimento & Cheese, Bread & Butter Tea Sandwiches, Sardine Tea Sandwiches (popular in the 1920’s), McLaren Cheese Sandwiches (McLaren’s Roquefort or Sharp Cheddar Cheese crocks). The tea sandwiches laid out on a doily-lined Gorham silver flat rectangular tray, covered with moist paper towels so they don’t dry out.
Southern Pimento Cheese & Bacon Sandwiches: Fry some bacon & set aside. In a bowl, add cream cheese & mayonnaise with pickled pimentos chopped, minced black olives, walnuts & grated cheese & bacon, cayenne paper and/or garlic. Spread on bread or bread rounds to make a canape with dill snip on top.
Cream Scones with Currants or Orange zest or Buttermilk Biscuits with Raspberry Jam & Strawberry Jam & Orange Marmalade (SMR), with small bowls of Lemon Curd & Devonshire Cream
Irish-layered Trifle: Lady Finger or pound cake, Cream or Tapioca, Chocolate pudding, Hot house strawberries or fresh berries or mandarin oranges or canned peaches, whipped cream, & minced nuts & chocolate shavings on top
Ambrosia Fruit Salad with apple, bananas, dried apricots, walnuts, mandarin oranges, in whipped cream or marshmallow cream
Cranberry Relish: cooked and grated cranberries, apple & ginger, with mandarin oranges, pecans or walnuts, orange juice (over apples so they won’t brown) & orange zest.
Brandied Peaches in a pretty fine china bowl with a small baby spoon to be served with pies or any dessert.
French Fromage or Cheese course: Brie, Camembert served with dried apricots and grapes, served with Afternoon water crackers.
Huntington Petit Desserts: French Opera Cake, French Petit fours: small round vanilla cakes with chocolate frosting or Chocolate Ganache
Afternoon Tea Cookies or Tea Biscuits: “Butter thins” cookies, Arrowroot Crackers, French Beurre Butter Cookies, Tea Wafers, Bonnie Doone biscuits, Vanilla Wafers
French Chocolate Bon Bons on Silver Bon-bon dishes (Chocolate truffle and peppermint from Huylers NYC)

Royal Punch (1899)
In the Gilded Age, high society emulated English & French royalty, especially Mrs. Arabella Huntington. She was very fond of French Queen Marie Antoinette & French Empress Eugenia (from Spain). Recipes published in magazines for “Royal Punch” or “Prince of Wales Tea” became quite a inspired fad in America. Personally, the calf’s foot jelly would have turned me off.
“Put a quarter of a lb. (1/4 lb.) of double refined sugar [super-fine sugar] in large lumps into a bowl & with it 2 limes & a thin slice of fresh lemon. With a bruiser, rub the sugar & the fruit well together, then mix thoroughly with 2 glassful of calf’s foot jelly in a hot state. Take brandy, rum, arrack,& curacoa [orange liqueur] in equal quantities & stir them into the preparation. When thoroughly mixed, add a pint of boiling green tea & serve hot. The quantity of spirits must be regulated by taste, 1/2 pint of each will generally be found sufficient. ” Rare book: Cassell’s Dictionary of Cookery (1899) Huntington Library San Marino, CA Nancy Note: “Arrack” is similar to rum, but it is distilled from fermented sugarcane, coconut flowers, grains, or fruit.
